Lead and zinc selective extraction from EAF dust while heating in resistance furnace with flowing argon

Introduction

The accumulation of electric arc furnace (EAF) dust in the dumps of metallurgical companies contains significant amounts of zinc (typically 15 – 25 %) and lead (up to 3 %). Given the limited reserves of zinc and lead ores¹, as well as the low content of these metals in the dust, it has become crucial to develop technologies for the selective extraction of non-ferrous metals from EAF dust. Reprocessing this dust would not only allow for the recovery of zinc, lead, and iron for metallurgical production but also address the issue of toxic waste occupying substantial areas [1].

In general, zinc and lead in the EAF dust are present in the form of oxides due to the oxidizing nature of the steelmaking process. However, in the gas flow, there is a high probability of the formation of complex oxides, such as zinc ferrite ZnFe₂O₄ [2 – 4]. Moreover, the diverse chemical composition of materials processed in the EAF leads to variations in both the chemical and phase compositions of the EAF dust. This necessitates continuous monitoring when disposing of metallurgical dust and complicates EAF dust disposal procedure [5].

Currently, selective extraction of lead and zinc from the EAF dust is primarily carried out using hydrometallurgical methods [6; 7] or integrated pyro-hydrometallurgical methods [4; 8; 9]. However, the hydrometallurgical process is highly complex and involves multiple technological stages that require large amounts of chemical reagents, overheated vapor, hot water, and energy-intensive equipment. This poses environmental risks as numerous production sites are associated with poorly regulated or unregulated emissions of spent reagents, heat, energy carriers, production wastes and by-products [10; 11]. Therefore, it appears advisable to explore pyrometallurgical methods for the reprocessing of EAF dust to achieve selective extraction of lead and zinc.

An overview of studies on the disposal of toxic EAF dust reveals that the majority of efforts are focused on conventional approaches that utilize excessive amounts of reducing agents, such as carbon, to lower the starting temperature of zinc and other metals recovery. However, this hampers the selective extraction of these metals during the recovery process.

Furthermore, the reduction of industrial carbon consumption to mitigate CO2 emissions has become a key objective for BRICS countries [12].  In Russia, specifically, government measures have been planned to address greenhouse gas emissions according to sources^2 3. These measures include:

– implementation of mandatory carbon accounting;

– establishment of performance targets for companies;

– implementation of fees or fines for excessive emissions;

– introduction of carbon emission trading;

– technological upgrades in production process.

These governmental actions impose restrictions on metallurgical technologies that are associated with significant greenhouse gas emissions. As a result, there is a need to develop methods for the selective extraction of lead and zinc from the EAF dust that do not rely on the use of additional reducing agent.

Object of research

The research focuses on the EAF dust from PJSC Severstal, which exhibits the following element composition (wt. %): 41.4 Fe; 14.5 Zn; 6.2 Ca; 2.5 Mn; 1.7 Cl; 1.74 C; 1.3 Si; 1.0 K; 1.0 Pb; 0.74 S; 0.2 Cr; 0.2 Cu; 0.1 Ti; with the remaining portion likely being oxygen. The determination of element content ranging from Na to U was performed using the MAX-GVM wave-dispersion X-ray fluorescent spectroscan specimen (MAX-GVM). This method involves exposing the sample to primary radiation from an X-ray tube, measuring the intensity of secondary fluorescent irradiation at wavelengths corresponding to the elements of interest, and subsequently calculating the weight fraction of these elements using fundamental parameter methods. Sample preparation involved milling and averaging loose samples, mixing them with a binder (polyacrylamide) at a concentration of 0.2 wt. % above the sample, wetting, forming the mixture into moderate-height cylinders (D = 7 mm, h = 2 – 3 mm), and drying. For solid samples, polished cross-sections were prepared.

The carbon and sulfur content was determined using a Leco CS 600 instrument through high temperature extraction in a carrier gas. The determination of carbon and sulfur involved combusting the sample in an oxygen flow (99.998 %) in the presence of special fluxes, followed by the measurement of the formed carbon dioxide (CO₂) and sulfur dioxide (SO₂).

The phase composition of the EAF dust was determined using X-ray diffraction (XRD). The phase content (wt. %) was found to be as follows: 78.2 Fe₃O₄; 4.4 (Zn, Mn, Fe)₃O₄; 6.0 ZnO; 4,5 Ca₂Fe₂O₅; 3.0 MnO₂; 2.7 Pb₂O₃; 1.2 SiO₂. It should be noted that since the structures of magnetite and spinel are essentially identical, they can be considered as a combined phase.

Theoretical objectives

Previous studies have suggested that selective reduction of lead from the EAF dust can be achieved with an insufficient amount of reducing agent. For example, it was demonstrated in [13] that during the reducing melting of lead agglomerate, selective reduction of lead can be achieved with a limited amount of carbon monoxide as a reducing agent (CO content not exceeding 60 %). Similar effects of solid carbon on the reduction of lead-containing industrial wastes were also considered in [14; 15]. It was observed that when the carbon content exceeded 3 %, combined reduction of lead and zinc from EAF dust occurred. Furthermore, when the carbon content exceeded 3.7 %, the selectivity of lead reduction from copper melting dust became more complex.

In order to determine the conditions necessary for the selective extraction of zinc and lead from EAF dust, it is crucial to identify the temperatures at which the zinc and lead compounds in the dust transition into the gas phase.

According to [16], HSC Chemistry 6 software has been successfully utilized to evaluate thermodynamic parameters, and the simulated results have shown good comparability with experimental data. The software employs calculating modules that rely on a comprehensive thermochemical database encompassing enthalpy (H), entropies (S), and reaction heat capacitances (C_p). By calculating changes in Gibbs energies, thermodynamic temperatures of reactions (ΔG < 0) can be determined. The thermodynamic simulation considered reactions involving the reduction, thermal dissociation, and evaporation of detected lead and zinc-containing phases, as well as the reduction of iron and manganese oxides.

Table 1 summarizes the reduction of lead oxide (III) and the subsequent transition of lead and its compounds into the gas phase. The thermodynamic simulation assumed a carbon monoxide pressure of 1 atm.

From Table 1, it can be observed that the reduction of lead oxide (III) and the transition of lead into the gas phase begin at temperature not exceeding 877 °С.

Table 2 summarizes the reduction of zinc oxide and the accompanying transition of zinc into the gas phase.

According to Table 2, the reduction of zinc oxide with consideration for thermodynamics starts from the temperature exceeding 958 °C. However, it has been demonstrated in [17 – 19] that zinc reduction from EAF dust can occur successfully in the temperature range of 925 – 1300 °C with an excessive amount of reducing agent.

Reduction of complex spinel (Zn, Mn, Fe)₃O₄, specifically zinc ferrite ZnFe₂O₄ (franklinite), by carbon and carbon monoxide upon heating is investigated. The reactions of franklinite reduction which begin in the temperature range of 0 – 1326 °C are shown in Table 3.

Reactions 4 – 7, 10 – 12 in Table 3 exhibit similar starting temperatures for the reduction of lead and zinc-containing phases, emphasizing the need for accurate selection of temperature and composition of the gas phase to enable selective extraction of lead and zinc from EAF dust.

Since the spinel (Zn, Mn, Fe)₃O₄, detected in the EAF dust is not included in the HSC Chemistry 6 database, possible reduction reactions were considered for the compounds iron or manganese oxides (Fe₃O₄ and Mn₃O₄). The reactions, which occur in the temperature range of 295 – 1400 °C, are summarized in Table 4.

In accordance with Table 4, reactions 15 – 25 can occur simultaneously with the reduction of lead oxide (III).

Since the transition of zinc-containing phases into gas phase will occur after the reduction of lead (and possibly other components of EAF dust), it is likely that the carbon present in the dust will be fully consumed for other components. Therefore, without an additional reducing agent, the mechanism for the transition of zinc into the gas phase will be the thermal dissociation of zinc oxide (as shown in Table 5).

The temperature required for reaction 26 is too high for industrial conditions. The starting temperature of thermal dissociation can be reduced by decreasing the partial pressure of the resulting gases through the addition of argon. In order to confirm this, a thermodynamical simulation of the equilibrium composition was performed for the reaction of thermal decomposition of zinc oxide using Terra software [20]. The temperature of reaction ZnO = Zn_(g) + O_2(g) as a function of the partial pressure of Zn_(g) is illustrated in Fig. 1.

From Fig. 1, it can be observed that a decrease in the partial pressure of Zn_(g) (by argon addition) would allow for a reduction in the temperature range of thermal decomposition of zinc oxide from 1970 to 1300 °C.

Theoretically, a similar approach can be applied to reduce the starting temperature of the reduction of lead oxide (III) in order to expand the range of selective extraction of lead and zinc-containing phases.

It has been determined that selective extraction of lead and zinc from EAF dust is possible using two methods (temperatures provided without considering the addition of inert gas to the system):

– consecutive reduction of lead containing phases (295 – 877 °C) and zinc containing phases (794 – 1326 °C) by carbon or carbon monoxide;

– reduction of lead-containing phases (295 – 877 °C) by carbon or carbon monoxide, followed by the thermal dissociation of zinc-containing phases (1970 °C).

The need to investigate the mechanism of consecutive reduction of lead-containing phases and zinc-containing phases from EAF dust is driven by the preference for operating the process at lower temperatures. This would result in reduced energy consumption and the ability to carry out the process without the formation of a melt.

However, the temperatures in the actual process may deviate significantly from the calculated values. In order to determine the actual temperatures for the selective extraction of lead and zinc from EAF dust, an experimental study was conducted.

Experimental

The experimental study involved heating EAF dust in the temperature range of 20 – 1300 °C using a vacuum resistance furnace with constant heating rate and a Tamman furnace under isothermal conditions with argon flow. Prior to the study, a blank test was conducted to ensure that the weight loss of the crucible did not affect the measurements of the sample weight.

The temperature in the furnace was monitored using BP(A) 5/20 thermocouple placed in the isothermal area of the furnace, inside an empty crucible.

After the samples were cooled, they were weighed and subjected to chemical composition analysis.

The carbon and sulfur content in the samples was determined using a Leco CS 600 instrument through high temperature extraction in a gas carrier. The element content from Na to U was determined using a MAX-GVM wave-dispersion X-ray fluorescent spectroscan (MAX-GVM).

Experiments in a vacuum resistance furnace

EAF dust from bag filters was subjected to processing in a vacuum resistance furnace (Fig. 2) equipped with a graphite heater (D = 65 mm, L = 300 mm) in the temperature range of 20 – 1300 °C. The furnace specification are as follows: P = 20 kW; U = 10 V; I = 2000 А; f = 50 Hz. The furnace is equipped with a water cooling system.

A total of 3 g of the dust was placed in a thin-walled alundum crucible (D = 19 mm, d = 18 mm, H = 40 mm, h = 38.5 mm). The layer height was maintained at 1.25 – 1.50 cm. Seven crucibles, weighting a dust total of 21 g, were placed in the isothermal area of the furnace. From the furnace chamber was evacuated air using a vacuum pump to reach a residual pressure of 10\(^-\)¹ Pa, after which it was filled with high-purity argon.

Subsequently, the gas was discharged into the atmosphere and the argon flow rate was set to 0.5 l/min. The furnace was heated at a rate of 15 °C/min, with the temperature reaching 100 °C in ~7 min. Once the desired temperature (800, 1000, 1100, 1200, 1300 °C) was reached, one to two crucibles containing the melted products were removed from the furnace and cooled in ambient air.

The appearance of the samples before and after processing in the furnace is depicted in Fig. 3. After heating, the samples exhibited a darkened color, likely due to partial reduction of magnetite. The samples processed at 800 and 1000 °C crumbled under light pressure, while those processed at 1100 and 1200 °C were easily milled in mortar. Heating to 1300 °C resulted in the formation of a melt.

After cooling, the samples were analyzed to determine their chemical composition. The actual weight loss of the samples after heating is presented in Table 6, showing a significant increase in weight loss at 1200 °C and higher temperatures.

The contents of lead, zinc (determined using a MAX-GVM wave-dispersion X-ray fluorescent spectroscan), and carbon (determined using a Leco CS 600 instrument by high temperature extraction in a carrier gas) in the EAF dust after heating in vacuum resistance furnace in argon flow are summarized in Table 7.

The extraction rate of elements as a function of processing temperature of EAF dust in the vacuum resistance furnace is illustrated in Fig. 4.

According to Fig. 4, heating the EAF dust with a constant rate at flowing argon resulted in a significant decrease in carbon, zinc, and lead content. The removal of lead and zinc from the sample occurred in the temperature range of 800 – 1200 °C, with a higher extraction rate observed for lead. The intensive removal of lead occurred at temperatures above 1000 °C, while the intensive removal of zinc started at the temperatures above 1100 °C. To further investigate the possibility of selectively removing lead and zinc from EAF dust, their behavior in the temperature range of 800 – 1200 °C needs to be studied under isothermal conditions using the Tamman furnace, allowing for similar experiments to be conducted.

Experiments in a Tamman furnace

EAF dust from bag filters of the gas scrubbing system was subjected to processing in a Tamman furnace with a graphite heater (D = 80 mm, L = 400 mm) in the temperature range of 800 – 1200 °C, with holding time: 3, 6, 9, 12 min. The flowing argon rate (high purity) was set to 1 l/min. The furnace is equipped with a water cooling system.

A total of 3 g of EAF dust was placed in a thin-walled alund crucible (D = 19 mm, d = 18 mm, H = 40 mm, h = 38.5 mm), with a layer height of 1.25 – 1.50 cm.

Once the preset temperature in the furnace chamber was reached (800, 900, 1000, 1100, 1200 °C), four samples arranged in a cartridge were simultaneously placed into the furnace. The time of sample placement into the furnace was considered as the starting time of the experiment. The samples at each temperature were held for 3, 6, 9, 12 min.

As the furnace temperature and holding time increased, the color of samples varies from brown, dark brown and dark grey to black, which is likely attributed to the partial reduction of magnetite. The samples held at 800, 900, 1000 and 1100 °C (for no longer than for three minutes) retained their shapes but crumbled under light pressure. The samples held at 1100 °C for three minutes, upon extraction from the crucible, retained their shape under pressure, but could be easily milled in a mortar. The samples held at 1200 °C required considerable force to be milled in a mortar. Meanwhile, the samples held at 1200 °C for more than 6 min were difficult to extract from the crucible.

After cooling in ambient air, the samples were weighed, and their chemical composition was analyzed by the aforementioned methods. The actual weight loss of the samples after heating in the amman furnace with flowing argon is presented in Table 8, with a significantly higher weight loss observed at 1200 °C.

The contents of lead, zinc (determined using a MAX-GVM wave-dispersion X-ray fluorescent spectroscan), and carbon (determined using a Leco CS 600 instrument by high temperature extraction in a carrier gas) in the EAF dust after heating in the Tamman furnace with flowing argon are summarized in Table 9.

The extraction rates of carbon, zinc, and lead from EAF dust as a function of holding time during heating in the Tamman furnace (800 – 200 °C) with flowing argon are illustrated in Figs. 5 – 7.

According to Figs. 5 – 7, during the isothermal heating of EAF dust in an inert environment, the concentrations of lead, zinc and carbon underwent changes.

Complete transition of lead into the gas phase during the experiments was achieved at 1100 °С (holding time: 12 min) and at 1200 °C (holding time: 6 min and higher). However, at 900 and 1000 °C, increasing the holding time from 9 to 12 min did not result in an increased extraction rate of lead when carbon was present in the samples. This suggests that there may be a combined process involving multiple reactions of Pb₂O₃ reduction within the temperature range of 800 – 1200 °С.

Simultaneously with the transition of lead into the gas phase, there was an extraction of zinc, amounting of 14.4 % (relative) (t = 1100 °C, holding time: 12 min) and 32.2 % (relative) (t = 1200 °C, holding time: 6 min and longer), respectively. This indicates a failure to achieve selective extraction of lead during the heating of EAF dust under the experimental conditions. Further heating of the EAF dust would likely lead to selective extraction of zinc, as it appears that lead was completely removed from the EAF dust during the experiment. It is possible to achieve higher selectivity in the extraction of zinc and lead by adjusting the process temperatures for specific dust compositions. At 1200 °C, the extraction rate of zinc reaches a plateau, while the carbon content in the EAF dust decreases to zero. This suggests that the reduction reactions of zinc-containing phases ceased due to an insufficient amount of reducing agent.

Comparison of the experimental data with the results of thermodynamical simulation in HSC Chemistry 6 software confirmed that the transition of lead-containing phases of EAF dust into the gas state can occur according to reactions 1 – 6 (see Table 1). Furthermore, the transition of zinc-containing phases of EAF dust into the gas state most likely occurs through reactions 7 – 8 (see Table 2) and 12 – 14 (see Table 3).

The carbon content present in the EAF dust was not sufficient for the complete recovery of zinc from its compounds, particularly due to the presence of manganese and iron in the complex spinel composition (Zn, Mn, Fe)₃O₄. In order to achieve the full recovery of zinc-containing phases in the dust sample, the addition of a reducing agent in the form of carbon or CO is required. Since an additional reducing agent is needed after the recovery of the lead-containing phase, the most effective approach appears to be the intensification of zinc recovery from the electric arc furnace dust by CO purging. Increasing the flow rate of the reducing agent allows for a reduction in the recovery temperature of zinc [21]. For example, increasing the CO concentration from 75 to 85 % at 1200 °C results in four-five times increase in the intensity of zinc removal to the gas phase [13].

Researchers [22] have conducted studies on the recovery of zinc and iron from EAF dust using carbon monoxide as a reducing agent at various temperatures within the pyrometallurgical process. The optimal working temperature was found to be 950 °C. However, they also observed the negative influence of other impurities such as alkali-metal chlorides (NaCl, KCl) and lead compounds. The impact of these impurities can be mitigated by implementing a selective extraction process for lead and zinc from the EAF dust.

Conclusions

Thermodynamic simulation was performed to investigate the selective extraction of zinc and lead from EAF dust. Two methods were determined to achieve selective extraction (the temperatures are given without accounting for addition of an inert gas into the system):

– consecutive recovery of lead-containing (295 – 877 °C) and zinc-containing (794 – 1326 °C) phases using carbon or carbon monoxide;

– recovery of lead-containing phases (295 – 877 °C) using carbon or carbon monoxide, followed by thermal dissociation of zinc-containing phases (1970 °C).

Experimental studies conducted in the vacuum resistance furnace with linear heating revealed that the removal of lead and zinc occurred within the temperature range of 800 – 1200 °C. The rate of lead removal was higher, with intensive removal observed at temperature above 1000 °C, while zinc removal was more pronounced at temperature above 1200 °C.

Additional corrective isothermal experiments carried out in the Tamman furnace showed that complete transfer of lead into the gas phase was achieved at 1100 °C (holding time: 12 min) and at 1200 °C (holding time: 6 min and longer). However, during this transition, the extraction of lead was only 14.4 and 32.2 rel. %, respectively, indicating a failure to achieve selective lead extraction during the heating of EAF dust in the experiments. It is expected that further heating of the EAF dust would lead to selective zinc extraction, as the lead has been completely removed.

A comparison between the experimental data and the results of thermodynamic simulation allowed the identification of the most probable reactions involved in the recovery of lead and zinc containing phases.